Taylor Swift just released her latest album The Tortured Poets Department, and her highly-anticipated “track 5” is a farewell to her love life in the United Kingdom, “So Long, London.”
The song is believed to be about her English ex Joe Alwyn, or exes if we include Matty Healy of The 1975. It’s a somber ballad detailing the collapse of their romance, underlined by a pulsating beat with writing help from Aaron Dessner of The National fame.
Taylor Swift is known for designating the fifth track on her LPs for the most emotional or personal songs. Fans have speculated for years about this so-called theory, and although the trend may have started as a coincidence, Swift has played into it with her more recent albums. The first record where she acknowledged the theory was her 2019 full-length Lover.
“So Long, London” has piqued our interest for a different reason, however. The melody presented in the chorus of this song is awfully similar to that of “So Long Soldier” by Baltimore pop punk band All Time Low, which was released twelve years prior in 2012 on their album Don’t Panic.
The similarities between the two melodies typically wouldn’t be enough to warrant raised eyebrows. But it’s not just the melody. Both choruses begin with the words “so long,” and that coupled with the melody is what seems so damning.
Are we claiming Taylor Swift ripped off All Time Low? No. But it sure does seem a little too close for comfort. Coincidentally, “So Long Soldier” also mentions London. The first verse details how frontman Alex Gaskarth emigrated from the UK to the United States: “Back in ’95 / A little boy from just outside of London / Took a fated trip across the ocean.”
It is worth mentioning that the two tunes in question are written in separate albeit both major keys, but even the tempo is close. A quick 160 beats-per-minute in “So Long, London” rivals an even brisker yet nearby 190 beats-per-minute in “So Long Soldier.”
What do you think? If I were on Swift’s legal team, I might go ahead and start penning a defense…
Since our last post about the most underrated songs by Ed Sheeran in 2017, he has released a collaborative compilation album, two full-length LPs, and numerous stand-alone singles. With the most recent release of his record – (Subtract), we thought it may finally be time to fill you in on the 15 new underrated Ed Sheeran songs. This list will only consist of songs released after ÷ (Divide). If you would like to see our previous list of 15 underrated songs, click here! Keep in mind, this is not a list of his best songs, just songs that are good but sadly overlooked.
Honorable Mentions
These songs would have made the list proper, but I either ran out of room or they thankfully seem to have gained a good amount of traction!
15. “Way to Break My Heart (feat. Skrillex)” from No.6 Collaborations Project (2019)
The third least popular song on No.6 according to Spotify…
Despite No.6 Collaborations Project being mostly, um, hot garbage, there are a few jewels speckled throughout. You might see the name Skrillex attached to this song and immediately assume the worst. (You’re telling me the guy who made “The A Team” teamed up with the guy who made “Scary Monsters and Nice Sprites”?) But in reality, the production elements that Sonny brings to the table on “Way to Break My Heart” are rather understated compared to some of his prior handiwork and could be considered moderately tasteful. While I don’t think I’d be shouting my praises of this song from the rooftops, I would still encourage listeners to give it one more spin. Somewhere in the back of my head, I can’t shake my suspicion that this song would’ve suited a different artist much more than it suits Ed. Nevertheless, despite that speculation in tandem with the lyrics feeling a tad underwritten, I still find myself mildly enjoying “Way to Break My Heart.”
14. “F64” (2023)
Not a single made for radio…
I’m not sure where to even begin describing this song and actually do it justice. A stand-alone single, “F64” is a sorrowful tribute to Ed’s late friend Jamal Edwards, the founder of London-based SBTV. SBTV was instrumental in providing a platform for underground artists to share their music, and Ed happened to be one of those artists. One could argue this is Ed’s first rap-centric tune in years outside of No.6; despite 2021’s “2step” having a bit of rhythmic flow in its pre-chorus, “F64” will more pointedly remind fans of past songs like “The Man” and “Eraser” with its rapid fire verses and heartfelt delivery. The live music video portrays the lengths Ed went in order to pay homage to Jamal and shows how emotional of a song this truly is.
13. “I Don’t Want Your Money (feat. H.E.R.)” from No.6 Collaborations Project (2019)
The second least popular song on No.6 according to Spotify…
In the verses of “I Don’t Want Your Money,” Ed exposes just how rough things can get on a personal level while living out what many would call the dream. Despite his astronomical rise to fame, he discusses the bumps in his relationships as well as his financial struggles. In 2014, Ed masterfully displayed similar notions on the × (Multiply) songs “Nina” and “The Man,” the hardship of always being on the road, touring from country to country and never being able to spend time with the ones you love. As he states on “The Man,” “Success is nothing if you have no one left there to share it with” and “But when I broke the industry / That’s when I broke your heart.” Although not as heavy or painstaking as those two aforementioned songs, he alludes to similar feelings on “I Don’t Want Your Money.” “There ain’t no diamonds, silver, or gold / That can replace a man’s love in a home” or “I couldn’t be more present, but I was in a mess / I remember being on tour, staying up on the phone.” It’s a catchy tune that reveals some hard truths underneath all the glittering gold. … Oh, and H.E.R.’s appearance is fantastic, as usual!
12. “Be Right Now” from = (2021)
The least popular song on = (Standard Edition) according to Spotify…
Album closer “Be Right Now” opens with one of my personal favorite verses on = (Equals), singing “Every teardrop, every wrong turn / Made the moment we found.” The instrumentation of this tune is intriguing, characterized by an uptempo beat and hazy piano refrain laden over wispy strings and an almost anxiety-inducing pulsing bassline. The second verse introduces a plucky guitar melody that admittedly could’ve been much more impactful, but a new synth “wall of sound” picks up some of the slack. The musicality reaches a climax during the bridge before giving way to a stripped-back final chorus. This last refrain truly encapsulates the lyrical message—all “the hurry and the noise” surrounds you for so long but Ed’s abruptly solitary vocals force you to just … be. Be right now, exist in the moment with no distractions, no outside sounds.
11. “Balance” from – (Deluxe Edition) [2023]
A bonus track only available physically on LP and a CD included with the purchase of the – (Deluxe Edition) vinyl…
With 23 tracks total (14 standard and 9 bonus) on –, it’s no wonder some great tunes have become buried and forgotten. Even more of an uphill battle, “Balance” is one of the four bonus tracks exclusive to the deluxe vinyl record which luckily came with a CD that includes those bonus tracks. (Unfortunately, “Boat (Reprise)” is still only available on flexi-disc at this time.) “Balance” features this laidback kind of vocal delivery, somewhat akin to “Dusty” from the standard version of –. Some unpronounced strings are ushered in during the chorus, as well as a skittering percussion beat. It’s a strange amalgamation that shouldn’t truly work in the recipe book, but damn, does it taste good! The lyrics leave a lot to be pondered upon; there are so many different directions we could go with the potential meaning of this song. But sometimes I like that unknowingness, the ability to apply your own interpretation to the material presented.
10. “Call On Me” with Vianney (2022)
A forgotten hidden gem…
“Call On Me” was a stand-alone single that eventually found a home on the French deluxe tour edition re-release of = in 2022. Made with French singer/songwriter Vianney, this tune offers a unique flavor in Ed’s catalogue. Ed has dipped more than just his toes in the realms of modern dancehall, Latin dance, Afrobeat, and reggaeton music, collaborating with artists like J Balvin, Fireboy DML, Burna Boy, Paulo Londra, and Camila Cabello on multiple occasions. But an acoustic French pop song? Consider me tickled pink!
9. “Stoned” from – (Deluxe Edition) [2023]
The fourth least popular song on – (Deluxe Edition) according to Spotify…
“Stoned” reminds me a lot of “Save Myself” from ÷, a song which carved out a spot on our previous list of underrated Ed Sheeran tunes. (I mean, he even sings “Save me” in the pre-chorus here.) This a bleak cut of introspection into how Ed perceives himself, his current habits, his motives, and his personal success in comparison to his peers. “All my friends have settled and grown / And then there’s me here dancing alone.” I suppose it’s a testament to how even being on top of the world can’t shield you from those negative voices in the back of your mind. The first verse expands on this a bit with the lines “Crowds will devour, I don’t need breathing space / Consumed by hopelessness and all my worries.” Furthermore, Ed reveals how he tries to cover up his pain by getting high, writing “I’ll keep bleeding and I’ll be stoned” in the chorus. Piano-based and quietly capacious, the instrumentation of “Stoned” bolsters the exposure and vulnerability Ed is putting on display here. With – still being rather fresh, I hope this track can continue to climb the ranks in popularity.
8. “I Will Remember You” from = (Tour Edition) [2022]
The third least popular song on = (Tour Edition) according to Spotify…
Ed has always done a fabulous job at approaching grief in his music. The excited hope of “Small Bump” turning into a heart-wrenching farewell, the reminiscence on an enduring romance in “Afire Love,” the raw specificity of the pain in simple activities on “Supermarket Flowers.” The man has mastered painting the highs and lows we experience throughout the process of bereavement. Happy memories remembered, but a vacant hole remains. “I Will Remember You,” a bonus track on =, seems to get overshadowed by its standard version predecessor “Visiting Hours.” While “Visiting Hours” is a great tune, “I Will Remember You” hasn’t remotely neared the same level of acclaim. This song offers that dichotomy of highs and lows; the instrumental beneath the vocals sounds relatively upbeat and the lyrics reflect on the fond, beloved aspects of the deceased, but there’s still that familiar ache of grief. That longing, that feeling of wanting someone right back beside you and yet understanding it will never be possible.
7. “End of Youth” from – (2023)
It’s a song written entirely by Ed, and it is just so damn good…
Written solely by Ed, “End of Youth” is a brutally honest display of the toll sadness and grief can have on one’s juvenescence. Do we lose our sense of youth when we face a depressive state? Is a piece of our own innocence taken to the graves of those for whom we mourn? Ed even briefly divulges his suicidal ideation over the years: “All my ups led to falls that led to trying to end my life.” On a brighter note, it’s rather delightful to see that Ed, age 32, still considers himself in a state of youth despite being a “geriatric pop star” by Taylor Swift’s recent definition. “End of Youth” is one of Ed’s strongest solo showings in quite some time and certainly shines on an album that already weighs as heavily as –. My favorite line would have to be “Can’t get a handle on my grief when every memory turns to tears.”
6. “Stop the Rain” from = (2021)
The third least popular song on = (Standard Edition) according to Spotify…
On paper, this is the sort of song I would feel some kind of vague apathy towards from an artist like Ed Sheeran. But in actuality, “Stop the Rain” is a diamond in the rough. Lively, danceable, and fervent, “Stop the Rain” features Ed’s more impassioned vocals on = and a bass-heavy chorus bound to get you moving. Plus, the lyrics impart some semblance of emotional depth, discussing the challenges of keeping your head up when others aim to bring you down. Ed reiterates an idea he’s routinely espoused over the years throughout his discography: it’s okay to cry. It’s okay to not be okay.
5. “Lonely Lovers” with D-Block Europe from Lap 5 (2022)
Well, I mean, did you even know this one existed?
Ed is featured on “Lonely Lovers” by hip-hop group D-Block Europe, delivering a solid verse and a fantastic chorus. Don’t be misled by the title—this song is yet another tune about grief and losing the ones you love, but more specifically friends. With poignant lyrics layered over a solemn guitar melody and smooth beat, “Lonely Lovers” is a painfully undiscovered gem. I personally wish Ed had promoted this tune more. And don’t fret, there’s plenty of Ed featured on this song if you’re not enthused by D-Block for some reason.
4. “Penguins” from = (Tour Edition) [2022]
The second least popular song on = (Tour Edition) according to Spotify…
This song was released on the deluxe tour version of = in 2022 as a bonus track. There’s a particular cadence in Ed’s voice on “Penguins” that echoes his older material: a bit clunky at times with some interesting lyrical choices (“We are penguins on the ice / We’re not meant to fly but God knows we can try”) yet endearing and quite charming nonetheless. The instrumentation is rather sparse in comparison to most songs present on =, once again reminiscent of his previous work. But when I mention the song “Penguins” to my colleagues, they look at me with confused expressions. And rightfully so—it sounds ridiculous! But hear me out, “Penguins” is a fantastic deep cut well worth your time.
3. “Sycamore” from – (2023)
The second least popular song on – (Standard Edition) according to Spotify…
“Sycamore” might very well end up being one of those songs critics will point to in order to illuminate how – is just a “folklore clone,” considering all the input from Aaron Dessner, the similar instrumentation and reflective state of melancholy. But I think “Sycamore” and most all the other tunes on – can stand on their own as authentically Ed Sheeran songs. This tune cuts deep, reminiscing on how the trials and tribulations we face throughout life only render our relationships even more “glorious.” In the opening verse, Ed sings “Worried about my lover and I’m worried about our child / And part of me was always in denial, it’s gonna take a little while.” His wife’s cancer diagnosis is something he actively processes throughout this album. How do you cope with the very real possibility of losing your lover and the mother of your children? As he states, “What a puzzlе is this to be in love / To be planting your roots thеn dig them up.”
2. “Borderline” from – (2023)
This beauty deserves way more than just 6M streams on Spotify…
A piano-driven ballad, “Borderline” features Ed’s falsetto vocals in the chorus, and although this isn’t his most impressive performance, it’s still admirable nonetheless. Lyrically, this tune is an emotional gut punch. Some lines sound like they could’ve fit in comfortably on an album like A Crow Looked at Me by Mount Eerie, such as “And the blackbirds, they fly / Like a frown on the skyline” or “Sadness always finds an in / Sneaks its way past, infecting everything.” Ed captures something I find difficult to describe in the production and mixing on this track: it simultaneously feels spacious and atmospheric yet so closed-in and claustrophobic, so vast yet intimate. So lonely, wandering adrift in emptiness… I feel as though that perfectly conveys the message and overall vibe of “Borderline.”
1. “Fear” from – (Deluxe Edition) [2023]
A bonus track only available physically on LP and a CD included with the purchase of the – (Deluxe Edition) vinyl…
“Fear” takes our top spot on Ed’s more recent underrated songs. It’s the perfect blend of everything you’ve come to know and love about Ed Sheeran. There’s a catchy chorus, a rap sequence, a fun post-chorus melody, a delectable mix of instruments, Ed’s great chest voice and falsetto, and some relatable lyricism. It’s a breezy tune that doesn’t take itself too seriously and yet still manages to feel momentous and undoubtedly genuine. One listen and you’ll have that chorus embedded into your brain, “Fear is a joy-killer / So f*ck what they say.” And of course you’ll try to keep up with his spitting verses and inevitably fumble over your words the first few attempts. With how exuberant the chorus and post-chorus can feel, it’s worth taking in the depth of the lyrics at hand. “You’re only human, they bleed just like you do” and “If they have a thought, don’t mean that it’s right / Because they said [it] out loud” will assuredly resonate with listeners in our current internet-consumed era. “Fear” is an absolute hidden gem and I pray it’s more widely released for all to hear!
I truly didn’t anticipate that all three of our most underrated songs would be from –, but what can I say? The record is one of Ed’s best, and with 23 tracks, of course some tunes will be stifled! Let us know what you think of our list down in the comments. What would your list look like?
You know what time of year it is. 2023 dawns on the horizon as we wave our farewells to 2022 in the rearview. This year has been good to us in terms of music; we were blessed with some incredible records and artistic feats, some songs that made us want to dance and others that left us balled up sobbing on the floor, as any good musical year ought to do.
Enough sappy chatter. Let’s jump into the list.
Honorable Mentions & Shoutouts
In alphabetical order by artist.
Alice Merton – S.I.D.E.S.
Architects – the classic symptoms of a broken spirit
Belmont – Aftermath
The Cactus Blossoms – One Day
Camp Trash – The Long Way, the Slow Way
Carlie Hanson – Tough Boy
Carly Rae Jepsen – The Loneliest Time
The Del-Vipers – Los Del-Vipers
Florence + the Machine – Dance Fever
Hayley Kiyoko – Panorama
The Heavy Hours – Gardens
James and the Shame – Human Overboard
JVKE – this is what ___ feels like
Kehlani – Blue Water Road
Lauv – All 4 Nothing
Lucius – Second Nature
Maggie Rogers – Surrender
Metronomy – Small World
Moonchild – Starfruit
Perfume Genius – Ugly Season
Poets of the Fall – Ghostlight
The Regrettes – Further Joy
Sea Girls – Homesick
Sharon van Etten – We’ve Been Going About This All Wrong
Sigrid – How to Let Go
Silverstein – Misery Made Me
Thick – Happy Now
Travie McCoy – Never Slept Better
Wet Leg – Wet Leg
The Wombats – Fix Yourself, Not the World
The Wonder Years – The Hum Goes on Forever
The Wrecks – Sonder
The 1975 – Being Funny in a Foreign Language
Best Albums
8. Bastille – Give Me the Future
Leading up to the release of the UK pop band’s fourth studio record, Bastille labeled their first three albums as a “trilogy” of sorts and stated that this new album would be a leap forward for the band. The first single “Distorted Light Beam” was dropped in June of 2021, causing fans to speculate the album would be released that fall. However, behind the scenes, the full LP was leaked by August, if not earlier. Supposedly due to conflicting release schedules with their label, Bastille set the album’s release date for February of 2022. In interviews around the fall season, frontman Dan Smith told outlets that if it were up to him, the album would have already been out.
Despite the botched rollout, Give Me the Future made its entrance in February. Near the end of August 2022, the band released an accompanying counterpart titled Dreams of the Past to make the full Give Me the Future record a double album, which was rather underwhelming—some of the songs were new, but some were simply interludes, covers, or alternate versions of prior tracks. For the sake of our review, we will solely be focusing on Give Me the Future, but certainly grant Dreams of the Past a listen, particularly songs like “Running Away,”“Eight Hours,” and “Family Ties.”
Give Me the Future has its highlights, but it also suffers from delusions of grandeur and a lack of cohesion. The soundscapes created on this album are almost too big for a pop record, thus the production causes some tunes to sound like they’re being squeezed into a tin can. Lyrically, the band is yet again beating the idea of escapism from modernity into the ground as they have done on their past releases. But this time around, they are laying out all kinds of ways to escape from reality, be it dreaming, entering virtual reality, skipping town like Thelma and Louise, shutting off the lights with a lover, or literally just dying so you no longer have to experience pain.
The strange anomalies on this album include the spoken word interlude “Promises” delivered by Riz Ahmed and the band’s first feature on an album in the form of BIM on the closing track “Future Holds.” (The band collaborated with Graham Coxon and Kenny Beats on their 2020 EP Goosebumps as well as numerous artists throughout their Other People’s Heartache mixtape series, but they never displayed a featured artist on a proper album.) Unfortunately, “Promises” is rather off-putting with lines like “Those that came before us suffered more, so is it so bad? / They carried us as hope inside their ovaries and gonads.” And put plainly, “Future Holds” does BIM dirty by piling on so many effects to her vocals that her true operatic talent doesn’t shine through.
Songs like “Plug In…” and “Stay Awake?” are ultimately languished by bottom-heavy production and overblown synths. All throughout Give Me the Future, Dan Smith’s vocals are coated in pitch-shifting or autotune effects, including the use of an ElectroSpit on the lead single (those vocals were done by band member Kyle Simmons). It’s understandable, these touches make things sound more futuristic and sci-fi-like. But it also rubs off as unoriginal worship of Daft Punk or poor imitations of Future Nostalgia by Dua Lipa. When Dan’s voice isn’t being circumscribed by vocoders and talk boxes, his vocals are disappointing to say the least; he has a wonderful natural voice, but the odd fluctuations between head and chest voice on “Stay Awake?” are ear-grating. His performance on the single “No Bad Days,” a tribute to his aunt who succumbed to cancer, is very squeaky—borderline whiny—during the verses and boring as all get out in the chorus (it comes off as try-hard). On “Club 57,” an ode to American artist Keith Haring, the acoustic guitar sounds like it was recorded with an iPod Touch from 2011 due to how flimsy and tinny the production is.
That spiel hardly scrapes the surface of my criticisms, so I’m sure you’re wondering how this album wound up anywhere near our year-end list. At the end of the day, I still find things to enjoy about this LP. The title track “Give Me the Future” is one of the best songs in Bastille’s discography with lush instrumentation, brooding percussion, dynamic vocal refrains, and lyrics which more or less sum up the album as a whole. Single “Thelma + Louise” is a quick shot of pop bliss, speckled with elements of ’80s music and a lovely “suck-out chorus,” as Dan calls it. The countless sci-fi and pop culture references on “Back to the Future” are intriguing and urges the listener to think about the broader implications at hand. Plus, the horn section displayed on that track is something a bit out of the ordinary, so it adds some flavor to the record.
“Club 57,” despite its poor treatment of the guitar and an at-times annoying whistle melody, is a catchy little tune about craving love and attention to the point of not knowing the difference, portrayed in the confines of an achingly glossed-over account of Keith Haring’s career and famed stints at Club 57 in Manhattan. “Shut Off the Lights” is a cheeky dance number characterized by a saxophone solo and by rhythms and instrumentation taking influence from Paul Simon’s monumental album Graceland. Smith himself being of South African descent, he gives a nod to the 1986 record in the line “Your hands are on, hands are on me / Grace landing onto your bed, there you are.”
All in all, Give Me the Future is Bastille’s weakest project to date. However, I still find myself enjoying a sufficient amount of the record, enough to recommend giving it a listen and apparently to include it on our best albums of the year list.
Taylor Swift’s previous record evermore topped our list last year, and we ended her entry by asking, “Does this style of writing and musicality signal the direction for her future projects? Or is this simply a fever-dream-esque glimpse into what she is capable of as an artist unbothered by the demands of the mainstream?” Midnightsseems to have given us the answer, and it’s the latter option.
Swift is placing the train squarely back on the pop rails with Midnights and leaving behind the woodsy, organic feel of her two “pandemic albums,” folklore and evermore. We knew Taylor had to come out of the woods at some point. With absolutely zero pre-release singles, Midnights is a strong showing, especially when evaluating the full “3AM Edition” of the record, but it pales in comparison to her past pop-centric projects. Her 2017 masterpiece reputation has yet to be topped, and Lover and 1989 are still incredibly resilient listens. Midnights has its highs and lows, as sleepless nights typically do. One night you’re out partying with all your best friends and the next night you’re bawling on the floor of your bedroom alone.
The album opens with “Lavender Haze,” a catchy and, well, hazy track characterized by falsetto vocals and lyrical critique on the media. Unfortunately, with Jack Antonoff heading the song’s production, there is a drum fill leading into the chorus which is extremely reminiscent of the track-defining drum fill on Lorde’s 2017 tune “Loveless,” also produced by Antonoff. When I hear this fill on “Lavender Haze,” it only serves to remind me how much more I’d rather be listening to Lorde’s Melodrama. (And ultimately, if you squint your eyes, Midnights almost comes off like a long-lost record Lorde would have made had she not opted for the sunshiny acoustic sound on her 2021 record Solar Power.)
Midnights offers up some more great tunes in the form of “Labyrinth,”“You’re on Your Own, Kid,”“Mastermind,”“Maroon,” and bonus tracks “Glitch,”“Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve,” and “Hits Different.” However, most of the remaining songs are merely mediocre; they have elements that truly stand out and others that detract so heavily. On the eleventh number “Karma,” the pre-chorus is absolutely delectable, but the lyrics of the song in general fall short when considering this is Taylor Swift we’re talking about. “Vigilante Shit” has its shock value going for it, but after the first listen or two, it’s just a boring, bass-heavy, mumbly song which goes nowhere. It doesn’t even describe any true vigilante shit!
“Question…?” has left listeners ironically stumped on what exactly is going on in this tune, and the bridge says the word “that” so often, it doesn’t even sound like a real word anymore. “Midnight Rain” sounds like a vacuum cleaner. Sorry, I can’t unhear it and now you can’t either. “Snow on the Beach” is a bit underwhelming as a collaboration, and the chorus’ line “Weird but fucking beautiful” had potential to be so much more creative had Swift not felt the need to cuss so frequently. (See also: “Flexing like a goddamn acrobat” on “Karma” versus the clean version “Flexing like a Vegas acrobat.”) I typically never have a problem with swearing in music, and I myself have quite the sailor’s mouth. But when there is a clear opportunity to write something more poetic and interesting and original, it’s exceedingly disappointing when the artist—an artist who has routinely proven they are perfectly capable of writing poetic and interesting lines—prefers to curse instead.
“Anti-Hero” is catchy and groovy, but the bridge is simply senseless. Swift is renowned for her gut-wrenching bridges, but on “Anti-Hero,” the music video directed by Swift herself depicts her hypothetical children and in-laws reading the will at her funeral, condemning her for not leaving them a hefty inheritance. Does she know that wills aren’t typically, if ever, read at funerals? And what does this have to do with any of the themes she’s established in the song? “Bejeweled” has a fun earworm of a chorus, but the line “Don’t put me in the basement when I want the penthouse of your heart” feels more or less out of place. It’s there to grab your attention and nothing more, like many of the memorable one-liners found throughout the album. On top of all the poor lyrical choices, the production on Midnights washes out Taylor’s voice and drenches it in vocal effects to the point of undistinguished haze and unnecessary ersatz-ness.
Again, I’m sure you’re wondering why this LP is on our list with all these disparagements. Despite all those criticisms, I still find room in my heart and musical rotation for Midnights. There is something charming and captivating about most of the songs here; “Maroon” feels overtly personal, “Sweet Nothing” is a pleasant depiction of her long-term relationship, and “You’re on Your Own, Kid” tastes like open-wound catharsis. Bonus track “The Great War” is an accurate representation of a couple’s first major argument through battle-torn metaphor, and “Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve” is a poignant illustration of Swift’s internal struggles surrounding her relationship and subsequent break-up with A-list songwriter John Mayer who was 12 years her senior. She details her feelings of losing innocence and understandably not being able to let it completely go. “Dear Reader” is a fitting deluxe version closer where Taylor warns listeners to not “take advice from someone who’s falling apart.” You’ve listened through the full album, drinking in her life stories and emotional experiences, and she wraps it all together by reminding you that, despite the gilded outer shell, she isn’t perfect.
Midnights is similar in that aspect. It isn’t perfect, but it doesn’t have to be. Again, it is a mid-tier album for Swift’s standards, but a mediocre Taylor Swift record is still better than most.
Harry Styles blew me away with his 2019 sophomore release Fine Line. It was an incredible album from start to finish, no skips. Plus, his self-titled debut in 2017 still holds up to this day. Hence, expectations were set high for his third long-player dubbed Harry’s House. While Harry’s House has its fair share of shortcomings, it stands tall and has plenty more to offer.
Harry aims for a more synth-pop style overall on Harry’s House. The guitars and drum kits are still present, but songs like “Late Night Talking” and “Keep Driving” rely on forefront synthetic melodies and the opener “Music for a Sushi Restaurant” is heavily shaped by synths and programmed drums. Obviously, none of this is negative, but it is a notable stylistic shift from Harry’s preceding albums. “Matilda” and “Boyfriends” are much more propelled by the acoustic guitar, and “Grapejuice,”“As It Was,” and “Cinema” all display prominent electric guitar lines. Horn sections are also introduced on songs such as “Late Night Talking” and “Daydreaming.”
My primary gripes with this album are the less-than-stellar production quality and surface-level lyricism. The percussion on “Daylight” is so washed out, I feel the need to take a q-tip to my ear in the middle of it all. The deep synths consummating the backdrop for “Love of My Life” are discomforting (does anyone else think something about this song is off-key somehow?). In terms of lyrics, Harry seems to focus on relationships and does so in the most understated ways possible. On “Daydreaming,” he writes, “Baby, loving you’s the real thing.” Once you read the title for “Late Night Talking,” you already have the full gist of the song. “Little Freak” offers the astounding lines “A wet dream just dangling” and “Tracksuit and a ponytail, you hide the body all that yoga gave you.” There’s nothing extremely alluring about this album’s lyrics.
However, I do have praises for some songs. “Grapejuice” is captivating; I’m not sure why Harry’s voice is muffled during the verses, but the chorus melody and the “3-2-1” counting throughout the tune are delectable. Despite the drawbacks, “Little Freak” displays another strong chorus, as does “Daylight.” “Matilda” has become a fan favorite with its ardent message about the possible difference between those you consider family and those who truly love you. “As It Was” has dominated the airwaves and music charts, and for good reason. It’s a catchy tune that appears to reflect on how things have changed—it’s up to the listener on how broadly they want to interpret this. Is it about pre-pandemic and post-pandemic? Is it about a relationship? Is it about growing up? That’s for you to decide.
Overall, Harry’s House is a welcomed addition to Harry’s catalogue. While it doesn’t land anywhere close to its predecessor Fine Line, it is still a robust record from one of this generation’s most eminent voices. Harry is forging quite the legacy with his consecutive homeruns, commercially and critically.
Conan Gray had been bubbling under the mainstream’s eye for years with his self-released singles and Sunset Season EP. He was nicknamed by many as “Lorde’s little brother” for his similarly nostalgic musicality defined by layered vocals and reverb-heavy beats. So when he unleashed his debut full-length Kid Krow in 2020, it was a welcomed yet surprising shift to hear him experimenting with more punk-ish styles. He worked closely with Dan Nigro on that record, who of course went on the next year to produce the monumental SOUR by Olivia Rodrigo in analogous fashion.
After Kid Krow, Conan subsequently released standalone singles like “Overdrive,”“Telepath,” and the collaboration “Fake” with Lauv, which all hinted at a more pop-oriented direction. But once he roared back with “Jigsaw,” a raucous track reminiscent of supergroup boygenius’ self-titled EP, the granular guitars and rough vocals were back in full force. The other singles for Superache“Astronomy” and “People Watching” further displayed Conan’s multidimensional approach between soft acoustic balladry and buoyant pop tunes.
Because of that, Superache may feel disjointed upon first listen. The album is quite front-loaded with pop bangers like “Disaster” and “Best Friend” while the acoustic moments like “Summer Child” and “Footnote” quietly await you in the back half with a box of tissues. He delves into a number of subjects, most revolving around love, friendship, family, and introspection. “Memories,” which was also pre-released as a single, is a melodramatic power ballad about an ex who just won’t leave things alone while “Family Line” enumerates all the tragically powerful ways Conan takes after his parents.
Superache is a positive step forward for Conan Gray. This album feels like him finding his own sound, however widely strewn it may be. With few uninteresting moments to be detected, Superache will keep you on your toes as Conan engages with many instruments, styles, and topics.
The Summer Set’s last album Stories for Monday was released in 2016. The band took a five-year hiatus afterwards, experimenting with solo projects and other ventures in entertainment. Of course, it was unbeknownst to fans (and probably the band members) if the band would ever reunite. But in August of 2021, the band recrudesced with one of their best singles, “Street Lightning,” an upbeat, ’80s-inspired pop rock jam. Later that same year, The Summer Set dropped “Back Together,” an earnest overview of frontman Brian Logan Dales’ thought process on getting the band, well, back together. Lines like “If the world is gonna end someday, I’ll send a message that says: ‘Just in case we don’t live forever, let’s get the band back together,'” and “The diehards on the barricade won’t care how long it’s been” perfectly sum up how both the artists and fans feel in situations like this.
Their first full-length project in six years was unleashed in 2022, symbolically titled Blossom. The band marketed this as the first part of a double album, promising the second part to be released in 2023. Regardless, Blossom, Pt. 1 was more than sufficient. Blossom is arguably The Summer Set’s most “punk rock” album in a very long time, and it’s really freaking good. (This is what bands like All Time Low wish they could sound like in 2022!)
With eight tracks clocking in at just 25 minutes, Blossom is a succinct sucker punch of tight pop rock drenched in nostalgia. The album carries two features with Against the Current appearing on “Teenagers” and Travie McCoy laying down a verse for “FTS.”Blossom is stacked with catchy hooks from front to back; every song just hits. All killer, no filler! There is zero fat on this baby! Brian Logan Dales sounds better than ever, and Jess Bowen brings the heat once again. Even with only seven full tunes, the band offers a wide array of styles and instrumentation. “My Own Medicine” spotlights a great acoustic guitar riff, and “Street Lightning” flaunts that irresistible ’80s flair the band attempted to achieve on the antecedent Stories for Monday. “FTS” (yes, fuck that shit) features a horn section with a delectable saxophone solo. “Hard Candy,” “Teenagers,” and “Famous” scratch that pop punk itch, even though “Famous” ends a little too early, in my opinion.
Blossom will have your thumb hovering above the replay button time and time again. An absolute barrage of catchy melodies and memorable guitar riffs, this is without a doubt The Summer Set’s strongest album in a long, long time. Thank God they got the band back together.
Best tracks: There’s only seven, just go listen to all of them. It only takes 24 minutes.
3. Bad Suns – Apocalypse Whenever
After 2019’s relatively boring Mystic Truth, the band’s third studio record, Bad Suns seemed eager to move on to the next thing. Frontman Christo Bowman admitted to this in an interview with Lucid Magazine after the release of Apocalypse Whenever: “We’ve been scaling a mountain for a while and I think we lost our footing, took a bit of a tumble, and lost our compass in the process while we were making our third album. … There’s a lot to be learned from what happens when you try to make something for somebody else and it blows up in your face. It’s like dying twice. You don’t love it, and most likely, neither does whomever you thought you were making it for. Life’s too short to give a fuck about them. Make music for yourself—you learn that that’s where the compelling ideas actually come from.”
We learned from the band’s first two albums, Language & Perspective and Disappear Here, that Bad Suns has some serious musical chops. But Mystic Truth, their first output on Epitaph Records, delivered mediocre indie rock tunes with little to write home about. There was increased utilization of the piano, but lackluster lyrics and comparatively elementary guitar lines left plenty to be desired. Unfortunately, the pandemic seemingly stretched the rollout for the band’s fourth LP, and at times it felt as though the hype was losing its steam. (The lead single “Baby Blue Shades” dropped in the early fall of 2020 with the album set for release in January of 2022.)
Nevertheless, Apocalypse Whenever displays Bad Suns getting their mojo back. Infectiously catchy hooks, concise guitar melodies, and refreshing production lay the groundwork for this record, as does the opening title track: “Life tried to make me somebody I’m not / Can’t separate from me, I’m all I’ve got,” a subtle callback to their 2016 track “Outskirts of Paradise.” Apocalypse Whenever is a rejuvenated testament to how brilliant the band can be when harnessing their own strengths.
After the opener, “Summer Lightning” is a rollicking pop rock tune speckled with some autotune effects in the verses but an absolutely massive chorus. “Peachy” is a lovely reflection on Christo Bowman’s time with his now-fiancée, as is “Heaven Is a Place in My Head.”“Electric Circus” provides commentary on the public making a shitshow out of technology, and the following track “Nightclub (Waiting for You)” is a forlorn slice of nostalgia characterized by warm synths and groovy percussion. “Silently Screaming” features continuation of that groove plus a saxophone solo and lush backing vocals. “Life Was Easier When I Only Cared About Me” supplies some of Christo’s best vocal performances on the record and some clever co-writing from Sierra Deaton. (Bad Suns × 5SOS collab when?) Bonus track “Life Jacket” offers up one of the band’s best guitar riffs in their entire discography with an undeniable chorus melody.
Ultimately, Apocalypse Whenever is Bad Suns’ comeback record. It might be their most “pop” album to date, but who cares? It feels so gratifying to enjoy this LP and know the band enjoys it too. As Christo states on “Summer Lightning,” “I don’t want this to end.”
2020 witnessed the release of 5 Seconds of Summer’s fourth full-length CALM, an acronymic title of all the band members’ first initials. While there were some great tunes on that record, I felt as though it didn’t quite live up to the band’s previous two albums, Sounds Good Feels Good and Youngblood. It seemed there were too many cooks in the kitchen, too many tugs in too many directions.
So 5SOS5 eliminated that problem. With the majority of the album being written and produced by only the band, the practically self-titled 5SOS5 is arguably the most true to themselves 5SOS has ever been. While some outside co-writers and producers were brought in here and there, the album still feels cohesively 5SOS, even as they explore new styles and sounds. Songs like “Take My Hand,” which was written solely by vocalist and guitarist Luke Hemmings, and “Bad Omens” carry a U2 kind of influence while “Best Friends” and “CAROUSEL” feel like a more grown-up version that pop punk style the band once possessed. The U2 inspiration also bled through to the album’s visuals with yucca Joshua trees dotting the lyric booklet and merchandise. There’s also an extended version of “Take My Hand” on the tracklist dubbed the “Joshua Tree Version.”
“Older,” a shuffling jazz-inflected tune, features Luke Hemmings’ fiancée Sierra Deaton, the first time 5SOS has included a featured guest on an album. (They released a version of their song “Lie to Me” with a feature from Julia Michaels, but that was not present on a proper studio record.) “Caramel” and “HAZE” go down smooth with slick guitar riffs and compact percussion all around. “Bleach” is a spacey yet vivacious ballad, and “Red Line” ends the standard album with a flighty lamentation on a relationship. Bonus track “Bloodhound” incorporates elements of “I Ran (So Far Away)” by A Flock of Seagulls—sampling and interpolation is something the band hasn’t done since their sophomore album in 2015.
All four band members contribute their vocals on this record, something of which CALM saw very little. Bassist Calum Hood and drummer Ashton Irwin dominate “HAZE” and “You Don’t Go to Parties,” and guitarist Michael Clifford monopolizes the bonus track “Emotions” and prominently shines on “Best Friends” and “Bleach.” Michael also served as lead producer for the album, working his magic on 12 out of 19 songs. (It’s also worth noting that between CALM and 5SOS5, we were blessed with two solo albums, one from Ashton Irwin and the other from Luke Hemmings. Each of those records landed high placements on their respective year-end lists.)
5SOS5 also presents some of the band’s most mature and compelling lyrics to date. “Shallow hearts for shallow minds that ache to be alive / You fall apart a redefine what keeps you at night,” sings Luke Hemmings on “Take My Hand.” “Best Friends” features the fantastic one-liner “It’s time to love somebody who won’t try to change your way.” “A youth that was stolen and filled with mistakes / I turned all around, looked for someone to blame / But I’m overdramatic and drenched in my pain / I know that you saw it all over my face” on “Easy for You to Say” offers a moment of reflection on the band’s quick rise to fame during their formative teenage years. “I know my mood’s been swinging all day / Weaponized words can get in the way / Nothing I say ever coming out straight / When I pull through, hope you feel the same” details the struggles of mental illness interfering with a relationship on the aptly titled bonus track “Moodswings,” a song that may remind listeners of those more emotionally gut-wrenching songs from Sounds Good Feels Good.
I could go on all day quoting lyrics, but then you may as well just listen to the album yourself for the full effect. This record is an experience from beginning to end. I would even dare to say it is their most robust album in their catalogue. Even if you’ve never paid mind to 5SOS or maybe you’ve only enjoyed one or two of their bigger singles, I promise you will find something to love on 5SOS5.
5 Seconds of Summer is my all-time favorite band, so you know something’s gotta be good to top their album on my year-end list…
1. Greyson Chance – Palladium
I never fathomed that Greyson Chance could top his 2019 album portraits. Not because he wasn’t capable, but because portraits was a masterpiece through and through. So when I heard Palladium, I was relieved and dumbfounded because Greyson proved me wrong. From the first single, which is also the title track, I knew he was already operating on another wavelength. With each following single ahead of the album’s release, particularly “Athena” and “Homerun Hitter,” I felt more and more sure that whatever Greyson was cooking up was going to be a grand slam.
I’m speechless; it’s difficult to know where to begin with my praises. Palladium has it all. It just goes above and beyond in every category: instrumentation, production, vocals, lyrics, hooks. Even the interlude tracks are miles ahead of most artists’ normal tunes. With zero use of autotune on the record, Greyson establishes yet again his absurd vocal prowess. His raspy lower register and elysian falsetto equally radiate on the album. Palladium integrates more organic instrumentation than portraits while still maintaining that poppy demeanor. Acoustic guitar and piano truly command this record without taking away from other elements.
Greyson employs a certain specificity in his writing that causes his lyrics to feel a thousand times more personal than most pop songs. He utilizes location many times which lends a sense of reality to these retellings of his lived experiences. “Up in Laurelvale drinking wine, staring up at the noose,” he sings on “Panthers.” The opener “Palladium” provides the listener with “Meet me in the pink light, right off I-75 / Right before the fall / You hop inside my car, with a tear / Say, ‘There’s nothing like the fear of losing truth.'” “My Dying Spirit” packs a punch in so many ways, but the lines “I’m so sorry, Alexa, I won’t make her graduation / But tell Sloaney girl she’s the apple of my eye / Tell her, take your time, take your time” always leave me breathless. “Aloe Vera” displays such detailed accounts of a lover with unmatched levels of personality; every line brings something new and extraordinary.
No matter what genres you find yourself comfortable in, Palladium deserves your time for at least one listen. I really could go on and on about every little thing I enjoy on this record, but I would essentially be breaking it down measure-by-measure at that point. Trust me, you won’t want to let this album pass you by.
Welp, that wraps up our favorite albums of 2022. It was an awesome year for music, so let us know your favorite albums from 2022 and your thoughts on our picks!